[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

+11
Death_X_Magi
hueman08
Eulogy
DonThompson
HorstRabe
^Grim
aChiiies
Mishotaki
Tangax
Dragonfire_92
s3rius
15 posters
Go down

You want Rank Icons in the next version of DotD?

2 - 22%
2 - 22%
5 - 56%
 
Total Votes: 9
 
Poll closed
s3rius
s3rius
LTG
LTG
Posts : 1916
realm_3
Réputation : 57
[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Pp_adm10
Regist Date : 2006-02-11

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Tue 30 Jun 2009, 20:23
A discussion has rising whether to add or not to add Rank Icons for DotD (See here)

Will put that up to public decision.

[x] Add only BTNs. That means that I add the icons, but remove their disabled versions. That would make the icons turn into an ugly green when someone pauses the game (until unpause). (They could also turn green on some other occasions.. I'm not sure. It happens more often in singleplayer, but very rarely in multiplayer.) Requires ~175kb of space.

[x] Add full icons. Nothing much to say. Adds BTNs and DISBTNs. Requires ~300kb of space, but does not show green icons at all.

[x] Don't add at all. Nothing much to say.

The rank icons would only be seen in the Multiboard so it doesn't have much visual impact on the game.
Or do you have any other places you'd want them to be displayed?
Adding 300kb would bring the map to ~3MB total size. Judging from the values of my host bot 300kb would increase the download time by about 15-20 seconds (would increase loading time by half a second at max. Not worth speaking of)

If you have a different idea, feel free to post it.
Dragonfire_92
Dragonfire_92
SSG
SSG
Posts : 39
realm_3
Réputation : 2
[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Pp_off10
Regist Date : 2009-06-12

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty Re: [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Tue 30 Jun 2009, 20:33
Dont add them at all. Better to save space for more items, mission, etc
Tangax
Tangax
MSG
MSG
Posts : 86
realm_3
Réputation : 1
[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Pp_mem10
Regist Date : 2009-05-11

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty Re: [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Tue 30 Jun 2009, 21:26
Add Full Icons, it would be awesome to have a new badge every time you rank up, will be a main pointer of ranking up and will encourage more people to stick around and play dotd, and would be very satisfying to see it next to your name on the on screen name board.

thats my opinion
Mishotaki
Mishotaki
BG
BG
Posts : 1018
realm_1
Réputation : 23
[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Pp_off10
Regist Date : 2006-09-23

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty Re: [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Tue 30 Jun 2009, 22:40
i don't think it's worth it for the little impact it will give... and the ranks are before the people's name in the chat in beta 7 (from what i've played) so it won't matter that much...
Tangax
Tangax
MSG
MSG
Posts : 86
realm_3
Réputation : 1
[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Pp_mem10
Regist Date : 2009-05-11

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty Re: [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Wed 01 Jul 2009, 01:05
isnt it possible to fit a little picture on the top right dash board next to their names, about the same size as the icon of their class picture? which is a minature sqaure icon
aChiiies
aChiiies
2LT
2LT
Posts : 258
realm_2
Réputation : 0
Regist Date : 2009-02-07

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty Re: [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Wed 01 Jul 2009, 07:58
that would be neat . makes the board more interesting to lok at
s3rius
s3rius
LTG
LTG
Posts : 1916
realm_3
Réputation : 57
[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Pp_adm10
Regist Date : 2006-02-11

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty Re: [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Wed 01 Jul 2009, 11:32
Tangax wrote:isnt it possible to fit a little picture on the top right dash board next to their names, about the same size as the icon of their class picture? which is a minature sqaure icon
Yes, it would mainly be shown there. With the same size.
^Grim
^Grim
MSG
MSG
Posts : 111
realm_7
Réputation : 0
Regist Date : 2009-02-06

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty Re: [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Wed 01 Jul 2009, 13:40
Well i don't really see any real impact the icon has on the game. I vote they dont be added. Already the map takes minutes to download in Garena (downloading by entering a host you do not have a map yet).
HorstRabe
HorstRabe
1LT
1LT
Posts : 349
realm_3
Réputation : 8
[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Pp_mem10
Regist Date : 2009-07-19

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty Re: [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Wed 05 Aug 2009, 11:23
since 1.24 there´s no need to save space, because custom map sice is increased to 8mb. and the few seconds more downloading time.... not worth speaking of i think. rank icons kick ass,- so i would say make a new survey and add the full rank icons Smile
Mishotaki
Mishotaki
BG
BG
Posts : 1018
realm_1
Réputation : 23
[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Pp_off10
Regist Date : 2006-09-23

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty Re: [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Wed 05 Aug 2009, 15:18
well people have been complaining about the slow downloading times already.... at a full minute at 40kb/sec....
avatar
DonThompson
MSG
MSG
Posts : 139
realm_1
Réputation : 0
[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Pp_mem10
Regist Date : 2007-01-09

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty Re: [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Wed 05 Aug 2009, 15:41
well Misho those people that complain are just impatient, they cant wait 1 minute to download the map? geez.
HorstRabe
HorstRabe
1LT
1LT
Posts : 349
realm_3
Réputation : 8
[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Pp_mem10
Regist Date : 2009-07-19

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty Re: [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Wed 05 Aug 2009, 16:49
ok. now how many people download at 40kbps? and wth should they complain about 1 (!!!!) minute!? i totally not aggree with them, because when they cant wait only 1 minute, they havent deserved this map i think... i mean come on, one minute?!

Rang icons kick ass, thats that,- and this map will NEVER get up to 8mb Very Happy
avatar
DonThompson
MSG
MSG
Posts : 139
realm_1
Réputation : 0
[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Pp_mem10
Regist Date : 2007-01-09

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty Re: [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Wed 05 Aug 2009, 16:52
Well I see it like this, does it make map look cooler? does it make have a purpese? Is there enough space in file to add it? If yes why not then? I dont see why not, someone said 8mb can be made of custom maps now, well afaik you have a lot left to fill those 8mb. So my vote goes for adding it, I dont see no points why it should not. People that complain that it takes 1-2 min to dl a map are just crazy
HorstRabe
HorstRabe
1LT
1LT
Posts : 349
realm_3
Réputation : 8
[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Pp_mem10
Regist Date : 2009-07-19

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty Re: [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Wed 05 Aug 2009, 17:00
/sign
Eulogy
Eulogy
COL
COL
Posts : 782
realm_1
Réputation : 17
[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Pp_off10
Regist Date : 2009-01-26
http://www.edge.ca

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty Re: [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Wed 05 Aug 2009, 17:12
lol give me a break.. map size increase by 300? thats what they are (general people dling the map) complaining about? go ahead and add the full thing its another 5 seconds for most people OoOoOoO big deal on their part... seriously s3rius if I don't care about map size when I'm DLing from the site for new versions why should other people? lol
HorstRabe
HorstRabe
1LT
1LT
Posts : 349
realm_3
Réputation : 8
[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Pp_mem10
Regist Date : 2009-07-19

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty Re: [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Wed 05 Aug 2009, 19:14
gogogo damnit^^
hueman08
hueman08
SSG
SSG
Posts : 42
realm_1
Réputation : 0
Regist Date : 2007-10-18

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty Re: [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Wed 05 Aug 2009, 21:10
I say yes. (:
Death_X_Magi
Death_X_Magi
MSG
MSG
Posts : 162
realm_1
Réputation : -8
Regist Date : 2009-07-08

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty Re: [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Wed 05 Aug 2009, 21:34
I'd like to see them too. If a person wants to play the game then they will wait for the DL if people can't then w/e. Patience is a virtue.
Proxy
Proxy
LTC
LTC
Posts : 720
realm_1
Réputation : 12
[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Pp_off10
Regist Date : 2009-06-02

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty Re: [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Thu 06 Aug 2009, 00:43
Hmm ): I didn't get to vote. maps can now be 8mb?! that's GREAT wasn't the max before 4mb? I think that if it only adds maybe 5 seconds load time to go ahead and do it there is plenty of space now it will make things look even better than they looked before and visuals really sell a map
Ryulink
Ryulink
RC
RC
Posts : 3
realm_1
Réputation : 0
Regist Date : 2009-07-29

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty Re: [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Thu 06 Aug 2009, 00:49
I cant vote too Sad, add full icons. It will be nice and it seen there wont be much consequence about it. If someone cant take 15-20 more seconds to download the map he doesnt deserve to play. IMO
hueman08
hueman08
SSG
SSG
Posts : 42
realm_1
Réputation : 0
Regist Date : 2007-10-18

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty Re: [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Thu 06 Aug 2009, 02:11
Well if you look at the date, it was June 30th. Maybe it was a timed poll, since this topic is more than a month old?
hammondo
hammondo
SGFC
SGFC
Posts : 51
realm_1
Réputation : 0
Regist Date : 2008-08-29

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty Re: [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Thu 06 Aug 2009, 02:33
My opinion is that most of the ZKS and ZDC crew have already trialed/beta tested beta 7 and other beta versions and liked/loved/enjoyed them (sure as hell i do Very Happy) which would mean that people dling the map will not worry about the tiny amount of dl time because they know what they will be in for....

Considering you can just dl from Epicwar.com let alone other gamers, means that you can be doing something more than just waiting for the map to dl....

Plus on the other hand we are a group that is commited to publish this map to anyone that is willing to listen and play properly thus making a few little icons may make it more appealing...

Personally i think they would be great... Only 300kb which will make the map a measly 3mb when you can create maps as big as 8mb...

Anyways if it isnt a huge success or people dont like it then there is always later Beta versions...
Gilorean
Gilorean
SG
SG
Posts : 25
realm_4
Réputation : 0
[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Pp_vis10
Regist Date : 2009-08-28

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty Re: [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Mon 21 Sep 2009, 10:02
Please dont add them S3rius. The map size is already too damn big - don't want to waste more bandwidth on these noobs down here in Bored Aussie server since we get alot of them.
Sponsored content

[Poll] DotD - Rank Icons Empty Re: [Poll] DotD - Rank Icons

Back to top
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum